Wednesday, 28 October 2026

$900K+ Lesson for Employers: Getting Reasonable Adjustments Wrong

A recent Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT) decision highlights the significant expectations that may be placed on employers when implementing ‘reasonable’ adjustments for employees with disabilities.

In this case, Boroondara Council was found to have unlawfully discriminated against an employee because it failed to provide a fleet vehicle that accommodated his disability.

Key facts of the case

The case concerned a Council worker whose role required him to drive extensively in a Council-provided fleet vehicle. The worker had previously sustained a workplace injury that left him vulnerable to experiencing a range of symptoms including neck and back pain, as well as migraines.

The Council replaced its vehicle fleet and allocated employees new vehicles as part of that process. The worker concerned claimed that the newly allocated vehicle aggravated his symptoms and requested to continue using an alternative vehicle that he said allowed him to perform his role without issue.

The Council did not dismiss these concerns out of hand. To the contrary, over a period of approximately 15 months, the Council:

  1. commissioned assessments by an occupational therapist comparing the existing fleet vehicle to the newly issued fleet vehicle. The assessments concluded that their relevant dimensions were almost identical;
  2. Considered evidence from both the worker’s treating practitioner and specialist; and
  3. Arranged an independent assessment by a doctor, which found no medical contraindication to driving a vehicle and assessed the employee as fit to perform the Local Laws Officer role without restrictions.

Having conducted three show-cause processes over the approximately 15-month period, the Council ultimately formed the view that the worker could not fulfil the inherent requirements of his role because he could not safely drive the Council issued fleet vehicle.

Why were the Council’s actions found to be unlawful?

Under the Equal Opportunity Act 2010 (Vic), employers must make reasonable adjustments for employees with disabilities where those adjustments would enable the employee to perform the genuine and reasonable requirements of the employment. Similar obligations also arise under the Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth) and other State and territory based anti-discrimination legislation.

In this case, VCAT accepted that extensive driving was a genuine and reasonable requirement of the role. Crucially, however, driving the Council’s preferred vehicle was not.

VCAT further found fault with the Council’s process in that it:

  • did not invite the worker to trial a range of vehicles;
  • did not have the ergonomic assessor observe him driving;
  • ruled out vehicles without testing the worker’s tolerance of them; and
  • did not adequately explore vehicles available beyond the existing fleet.

VCAT also considered the additional cost of a suitable vehicle negligible in context.

Consequently, VCAT found that the Council directly discriminated against the worker and set compensation at $901,160 (including $147,443 for past lost income, $626,025 for future lost income, $35,000 in non-economic loss plus past and future superannuation contributions), finding the worker would have continued working into his 60s.

VCAT indicated the parties should consider reinstatement, noting if they intended to attend a compulsory conference, the Council was to compensate the officer $200,020, followed by the $701,140 balance if reinstatement discussions fail.

Implications for employers

The implications of this case must be considered in their context – it will not always be expected that an employee can dictate the vehicle of their choice.

In saying this, it is clear that employers must adopt a considered and genuine approach to implementation of workplace adjustments.

In doing so, it is critical that employers:

  • clearly define the inherent/genuine and reasonable requirements of the role;
  • adopt a genuinely consultative approach to requests for workplace adjustments and management of fitness for work processes; and
  • genuinely give consideration to practical adjustments and alternatives, and form conclusions as to what is reasonable based on clear evidence, genuine operational considerations (including but not limited to cost) and safety of both the worker and others in the workplace.

HR Legal regularly advises and conducts training for employers on management of injured workers, reasonable adjustments and workplace assessments. Please contact us should you require support.

Share:
LinkedInFacebookTwitterEmailPrint

This article was produced by HR Legal. It is intended to provide general information only in summary format on legal issues. It does not constitute legal advice, and should not be relied on as such.


Related Event

Upcoming Event

Webinar: All I Want for Christmas Is… No Employment Claims

  • Thursday, 19 November 2026

Your guide to managing end-of-year functions and festive season risks The festive season is a time to celebrate achievements, thank employees for their hard work and connect with colleagues and clients. However, Christmas parties, client events and end-of-year functions can also create significant workplace risks, with employers often facing complaints, investigations and legal claims arising... Read more » Register